Schedule a Consultation

FCHC Helps Secure $220 Million Verdict Against Michelin for Gaines County Family

October 30, 2026

On July 12, 2021, three generations of one West Texas family were driving on a county road in Gaines County when the front tire of their Ford Excursion failed. The tread separated, the SUV crossed into oncoming traffic, and the head-on collision took the lives of a grandmother, her daughter, and her 14-year-old granddaughter.

In December 2025, a New Mexico jury held Michelin North America fully accountable, returning a verdict of $220 million in this product liability and wrongful death case. Fadduol, Cluff, Hardy & Conaway is proud to have represented this family as part of the trial team.

The Case Against Michelin

The tire was a Michelin LTX M/S2, an all-season tire sold for trucks and SUVs. The trial team argued the tire was defective when it left Michelin’s factory and that Michelin failed to warn drivers of the danger.

Michelin fought hard to keep key internal emails and documents out of the case, taking that fight all the way to the New Mexico Supreme Court. The court denied its request. Those documents became central evidence at trial.

After roughly two weeks of testimony in the Fourth Judicial District Court in San Miguel County, the jury found Michelin 100% responsible. The retailer that sold the tire was not found at fault.

FCHC’s Role

FCHC attorneys Jeff Cluff and Jodee Rankin were part of the trial team, working alongside co-counsel Kaster, Lynch, Farrar & Ball to secure this historic result for our clients. The verdict was later recognized on TopVerdict’s list of the Top 50 Verdicts of 2025.

Hurt by a Defective Tire or Vehicle Part?

Product defect cases pit families against global corporations with deep pockets and large legal teams. FCHC has been standing up for injured people across Texas and New Mexico since 1984. If you or someone you love was hurt in a crash caused by a tire blowout or defective part, contact our team for a free consultation. Offices in Lubbock, Fort Worth, Odessa, Albuquerque, and Hobbs.

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome in any future case.